Best Selling Engagement Rings
Our best-selling engagement rings are the ones couples choose again and again — celestial settings, nature-drawn designs, and alternative gemstones you won't find in a standard jewelry case. Each is handcrafted in recycled precious metals with responsibly sourced stones, from moissanite solitaires to color-shifting alexandrite. If you want a ring that feels personal and unmistakably different, start here.
Skye Kite® Green Moss Agate Ring in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$160
$135
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Green Moss Agate Ring Set in 14K Yellow Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$200
$170
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Aquamarine & Moonstone Fairy Leaf Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Galaxy Raw Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Sterling Silver (Salt & Pepper Diamond)
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Moss Agate & Emerald Fairy Leaf Ring in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Natural Red Garnet Kite Engagement Ring Set in Black Rhuthenium
$135
- Unit price
- /per
Starry Night® Crescent Moon Engagement Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Feyra Starry Night® & Amethyst Ring Set in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$200
$170
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Green Moss Agate Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Starry Night® Engagement Ring in Sterling Silver (Hidden Halo)
Regular price
$160
$135
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Starry Night® Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Wisteria Alexandrite Fairy Leaf Ring in Sterling Silver (Two Piece)
Regular price
$185
$155
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Galaxy Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Black Ruthenium
Regular price
$195
$165
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Fairy Amethyst & Simulated Diamond Engagement Leaf Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Kite Galaxy Sandstone (Starry Night®) Ring Set in Black Ruthenium
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Wisteria Alexandrite Fairy Leaf Ring in Black Ruthenium (Two Piece)
Regular price
$220
$185
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Simulated Diamond Bridal Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Cornflower Blue Sapphire Leaf Engagement Ring in Black Ruthenium
Regular price
$160
$135
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Peacock Fire Opal & Emerald Engagement Ring Set in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$195
$165
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Esme Gray Moissanite & Black Onyx Ring in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$190
$160
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Alice Teardrop Moonstone Engagement Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Starry Night® & Opal Leaf Ring in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$160
$135
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Green Moss Agate & Emerald Fairy Leaf Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Feyra Natural Amethyst & Simulated Diamond Engagement Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$185
$155
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Rutilated Quartz & Black Onyx Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Starry Night® & Sapphire Leaf Engagement Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Green Moss Agate Engagement Ring Set in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$200
$170
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Lilith Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
Elain Black Onyx Dark Fairy Leaf Ring in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$160
$135
(-16%)
- Unit price
- /per
Skye Kite® Alexandrite Ring Set in Sterling Silver
Regular price
$195
$165
(-15%)
- Unit price
- /per
Starry Night® Blue Fire Opal & Sapphire Ring in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil
Regular price
$175
$150
(-14%)
- Unit price
- /per
You’re viewing 1-32 of 100 products
Free U.S. Shipping
Dispatched from the USA with care
Hustle-Free Returns & Exchanges
Simple, worry-free process
Ethically Crafted
Responsibly sourced, consciously made
Loved by 200,000+ Couples
Fantasy-inspired, handcrafted jewelry
These are the rings our customers choose most — the most popular designs across the Aquamarise® collection, earned through thousands of proposals and promises. You'll find the celestial glow of our Starry Night™ rings, the color-changing magic of alexandrite, the soft blush of morganite, the luminous shimmer of moonstone, and the dark romance of our Lovers of the Dark™ and coffin-cut sets in blackened ruthenium.
Most are handcrafted in 925 sterling silver and 14K gold vermeil and priced from around $105, each set by hand with honestly disclosed stones and backed by a 4.9-star rating across 38,000+ verified reviews. Explore the full range of gemstone engagement rings, personalize any piece with complimentary engraving, or design your own through our Build Your Custom Ring service.
Shop Bestselling Engagement Rings by Setting
Explore popular engagement ring settings
Shop by Theme
Our favorites, all in one place.
Nature-Inspired Engagement Rings
Explore nature inspired engagement rings featuring leaf motifs, organic textures, and gemstone designs that capture the beauty of the natural world.
Shop Nature Inspired Rings
Alternative Engagement Rings
Discover alternative engagement rings with unique gemstones, bold designs, and non-traditional styles for those who want something different.
Explore Alternative Rings
Geometric Engagement Rings
Shop geometric engagement rings with clean lines, modern shapes, and distinctive settings designed for a contemporary, structured look.
Shop Geometric RingsFrom the Blog
How to Layer Necklaces: The Complete Styling Guide
How to layer necklaces like a stylist: the golden rules, best lengths and spacing, layering for every neckline, mixing metals, easy combinations, and avoiding tangles.
Types of Earrings: The Complete Style Guide
A complete guide to the types of earrings: studs, hoops, drops, dangles, threaders and more, by style and backing, plus how to choose for your face shape and occasion.
Necklace Length Guide: Chain Sizes & How to Choose
Necklace length guide: standard necklace sizes explained with a chart, where each sits on the body, how to choose the right length, and how to measure.
Gothic Necklaces: Dark Romantic Styles Guide
A guide to gothic necklaces: what defines dark-romantic style, black onyx and dark gemstones, signature Lovers of the Dark and Night Court pieces, and how to style and care for...
Best Selling Engagement Ring FAQs
Our most popular engagement rings are the celestialStarry Night™designs, the signatureSkye Kite®sets, and the gothicLovers of the Dark™coffin-cut rings, spanning alexandrite, morganite, moonstone, garnet, and more.
Most best selling engagement rings are handcrafted in 925 sterling silver and 14K gold vermeil, priced from around $105, making them an accessible way to own a distinctive, handmade design.
Yes — every ring is handcrafted with honestly disclosed stones and rated 4.9 stars across 38,000+ verified reviews, from an Etsy seller since 2016. Each can be personalized with complimentaryengraving.
Yes — most designs can be customized by metal, stone, and size, and ourBuild Your Custom Ringservice builds a fully bespoke ring, typically within 2 to 5 weeks.




