Your cart

Your cart is empty

Black and white image of a starry night sky with a nebula.

Herkimer Diamond Engagement Rings

Nearly 500 million years in the making, Herkimer diamonds are not cut into brilliance; they are born with it. Doubly terminated and naturally faceted, each crystal holds light in a way that feels almost otherworldly, sharp, luminous, and untouched by human intervention. Found only in Herkimer County, New York, these rare formations carry a deep intensity and a raw elegance that defy convention. Aquamarise® sets each gemstone for engagement rings with restraint and intention, allowing its natural geometry to remain the focal point. This is not brilliance manufactured, but discovered, preserved, and elevated into something profoundly enduring.

Skye Kite® Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring Set in 14K White Gold (Salt & Pepper Diamond) by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a kite-cut salt and pepper diamond with sparkling white gold accents.
Sale

Skye Kite® Galaxy Raw Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Sterling Silver (Salt & Pepper Diamond)

Regular price $135 from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Skye Kite® Galaxy Herkimer Diamond & Meteorite Couples Ring Set by Aquamarise featuring a kite-shaped Herkimer diamond with meteorite and diamond accents in a black finish band.
Sale

Skye Kite® Galaxy Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Black Ruthenium

Regular price from $148.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Lilith Coffin Cut Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a unique coffin-cut salt and pepper diamond with intricate white gold and diamond accents.
Sale

Lilith Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Sterling Silver

Regular price from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Skye Kite® Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring Set in 14K Solid Rose Gold by Aquamarise Gold featuring a kite-cut Herkimer diamond with pear and round accent stones in rose gold.
Sale

Skye Kite® Galaxy Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil

Regular price from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Skye Kite® Galaxy Herkimer Diamond & Meteorite Couples Ring Set by Aquamarise, featuring a unique black diamond-shaped Herkimer diamond with gold and sparkling diamond accents.
Sale

Skye Kite® Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in 14K Yellow Gold Vermeil

Regular price from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Engagement Ring- Black Rhodium Filled by Aquamarise featuring a unique coffin cut diamond with sparkling side stones on a black rhodium band.
Sale

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Engagement Ring- Black Rhodium Filled

Regular price from $94.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Black Moissanite Leaf Ring Guard in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold featuring an open vine design with marquise and round black moissanite stones and a central salt and pepper diamond, part of Solid Gold Engagement Rings and Lovers of the Dark™ collections.
Sale

Salt and Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond & Black Onyx Leaf Ring Set in Sterling Silver

Regular price $135 from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Ring Set in Sterling Silver by Aquamarise, featuring a raw hexagon diamond with leaf and diamond accents, a unique nature-inspired design.
Sale

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Ring Set in Sterling Silver

Regular price from $121.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Silver ring with a large, rectangular, black diamond on a light purple background
Sale

Elongated Hexagon Herkimer Diamond Ring in Sterling Silver

Regular price from $103.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Natural Herkimer Diamond Hexagon Ring Set in Sterling Silver by Aquamarise, featuring a raw hexagon herkimer diamond with salt and pepper inclusions and sparkling accents in sterling silver.
Sale

Natural Herkimer Diamond Hexagon Ring Set in Sterling Silver

Regular price $135 $121.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond Ring Set- 14K Rose Gold Vermeil by Aquamarise, featuring a teardrop salt and pepper diamond with sparkling accents on rose gold vermeil bands.
Sale

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond Ring Set- 14K Rose Gold Vermeil

Regular price $135 $121.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

A sterling silver ring featuring a kite-cut Herkimer diamond with salt and pepper inclusions, accompanied by smaller clear stones on the band.
Sale

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper (Herkimer Diamond) Leaf Ring in Sterling Silver

Regular price $105 from $94.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Natural Herkimer Diamond Leaf Engagement Ring in Sterling Silver by Aquamarise, featuring an oval raw diamond with organic inclusions on a nature-inspired silver leaf band.
Sale

Natural Herkimer Diamond Leaf Engagement Ring in Sterling Silver

Regular price $105 $94.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Diamond ring with a central black diamond and pear-shaped side stones on a reflective surface with a blurred purple background.

Elowen Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Sterling Silver

$155

Unit price
per 

Galaxy Salt and Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond & Meteorite Couples Ring Set by Aquamarise, featuring a rose gold band with an oval salt and pepper diamond centerpiece surrounded by leaf-shaped white gemstones, blending celestial charm with romantic elegance.
Sale

Salt and Pepper Diamond Leaf Ring Set in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil (Herkimer Diamond)

Regular price $135 from $121.50 Up to (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Natural Herkimer Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring in 14K Solid Rose Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a unique raw Herkimer diamond and moissanite accents in an elegant celestial design.
Sale

Natural Herkimer Diamond Cluster Ring in 14K Rose Gold Vermeil

Regular price $105 from $94.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Skye Kite® Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring Set in 14K Solid Rose Gold by Aquamarise Gold featuring a kite-cut Herkimer diamond with pear and round accent stones in rose gold.
Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Ring Set- 14K Rose Gold Vermeil featuring a hexagon salt and pepper gemstone with diamond accents on a rose gold vermeil band by Aquamarise.
Sale

Galaxy Raw Salt & Pepper Diamond (Herkimer Diamond) Ring Set- 14K Rose Gold Vermeil

Regular price from $112.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a hexagon-cut natural Herkimer diamond center stone flanked by triangular sparkling side stones set on a delicate diamond-accented band, part of Solid Gold Engagement Rings and Nature-Inspired Engagement Rings collections.
Sale

Hexagon Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring in Sterling Silver

Regular price $135 $121.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Toi Et Moi Salt & Pepper Herkimer Diamond & Black Onyx Ring in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a hexagon-cut Herkimer diamond and pear-cut black onyx in a gothic engagement style.
Sale

Toi Et Moi Salt & Pepper Herkimer Diamond & Onyx Ring in Sterling Silver

Regular price $135 $121.50 (-10%)

Unit price
per 

Skye Kite® Black Onyx and Herkimer Diamond Ring Set- 14K Solid Yellow Gold by Aquamarise Gold features a striking kite-cut black onyx centerpiece with salt and pepper Herkimer diamonds and delicate sparkle, perfect for unique and fantasy-inspired engagement rings.
Lilith Coffin Cut Natural Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in Solid 14K Rose Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a unique coffin-cut natural Herkimer diamond accented by delicate sparkling stones, part of Solid Gold Engagement Rings and Alternative Engagement Rings collections.
Diamond ring with a central black diamond and pear-shaped side stones on a reflective surface with a blurred purple background.
Galaxy Salt and Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond & Meteorite Couples Ring Set by Aquamarise, featuring a rose gold band with an oval salt and pepper diamond centerpiece surrounded by leaf-shaped white gemstones, blending celestial charm with romantic elegance.
white gold salt and pepper diamond ring set
Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a hexagon-cut natural Herkimer diamond center stone flanked by triangular sparkling side stones set on a delicate diamond-accented band, part of Solid Gold Engagement Rings and Nature-Inspired Engagement Rings collections.
Oval Cut Natural Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold featuring a unique oval Herkimer diamond with natural inclusions set in a delicate band accented with leaf-inspired detailing and small white stones, part of nature-inspired and alternative engagement ring collections.
Natural Herkimer Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring in 14K Solid Rose Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a unique raw Herkimer diamond and moissanite accents in an elegant celestial design.
Toi Et Moi Salt & Pepper Herkimer Diamond & Black Onyx Ring in 14K White Gold by Aquamarise Gold, featuring a hexagon-cut Herkimer diamond and pear-cut black onyx in a gothic engagement style.

Free U.S. Shipping

Dispatched from the USA with care

Hustle-Free Returns & Exchanges

Simple, worry-free process

Ethically Crafted

Responsibly sourced, consciously made

Loved by 200,000+ Couples

Fantasy-inspired, handcrafted jewelry

Aquamarise® Herkimer diamond engagement rings are offered in leaf-inspired, kite-cut, and Art Deco-influenced settings, designed to complement the crystal’s natural structure. Available in 925 sterling silver, black ruthenium, and solid 14K gold, each piece is built around genuine Herkimer diamonds sourced from their single origin in New York. Unlike traditional gemstones, these quartz crystals form with natural terminations and high clarity, creating their own reflective surfaces without faceting. Design choices prioritize openness and light exposure, allowing the stone’s natural geometry to remain visible. Each listing includes material details, durability considerations, and care guidance to support long-term wear and preservation.

white gold salt and pepper diamond ring set

Why Choose Aquamarise® Herkimer Diamond Engagement Rings?

Aquamarise® Herkimer diamond engagement rings are for buyers who want a stone with genuine geological rarity, a specific origin story, and an optical character that no faceted gemstone replicates in the same way.

A Stone With a Specific Origin

Herkimer diamonds are not found everywhere. They form exclusively in Herkimer County, New York, in approximately 500-million-year-old dolostone deposits, where the specific pressure, temperature, and mineral conditions that produce doubly-terminated quartz crystals of this clarity and quality exist nowhere else on Earth. Every Herkimer diamond at Aquamarise® is a genuine crystal from its specific geological origin, giving the stone a provenance that most engagement ring gemstones simply do not have.

Dark Settings

Herkimer diamonds are clear to translucent with natural inclusions that catch light in ways that vary with every stone. Against a dark metal frame, that contrast becomes pronounced. The Skye Kite® Galaxy Herkimer Diamond Ring Set in black ruthenium is one example, pairing the kite-cut crystal with a black ruthenium finish over sterling silver in an Art Deco-influenced design where the stone's clarity and light refraction read with maximum visual impact against the dark metal. Several dark-setting Herkimer diamond designs like this exist across the collection for buyers drawn to the gothic and cosmic aesthetic.

Nature-Inspired Settings That Connect to the Stone's Character

Herkimer diamond's raw, organic formation connects naturally to botanical and nature-inspired settings because both reference the same unpolished natural world. The Salt and Pepper (Herkimer) Diamond & Black Onyx Leaf Ring Set in sterling silver is one example, pairing a 1.2ct natural Herkimer diamond with deep black onyx side stones in a leaf-inspired band where the stone's galaxy-like shimmer and the botanical detail belong to the same visual language. Several nature-inspired Herkimer diamond designs are available across the collection for buyers whose aesthetic aligns with the organic and earth-formed.

Raw Optical Character No Faceted Stone Replicates

A Herkimer diamond's light refraction comes from its natural double termination rather than from cutting and polishing. The result is a sparkle that differs from that of a brilliant-cut diamond or moissanite because the light enters and exits the crystal through its natural faces rather than through mathematically arranged facets. That optical quality is unique to the Herkimer formation and cannot be reproduced in any other gemstone or through any cutting technique. For buyers who want a ring that looks genuinely different from every other ring in a room, a Herkimer diamond achieves that without requiring an unusual setting to do it.

Sterling silver leaf guard wedding band and oval salt and pepper (Herkimer diamond) engagement ring displayed in hand against warm brown backdrop

Popular Settings & Styles for Herkimer Diamond Engagement Rings

Aquamarise® Herkimer diamond engagement rings are available across leaf-motif, kite-cut, and Art Deco-influenced settings in 925 sterling silver, black ruthenium, and solid 14K gold. Shop by setting across Solitaire Engagement Rings, Halo Engagement Rings, Vintage Antique Engagement Rings, and Nature-Inspired Engagement Rings. Shop by style across Kite Cut Engagement Rings, the Skye Kite® Collection, and Alternative Engagement Rings. Use the filters above to shop by setting or metal.

From the Blog

Herkimer Diamond vs Salt and Pepper Diamond - Which Is Right for Your Ring?

Herkimer Diamond vs Salt and Pepper Diamond - Which Is Right for Your Ring?

A complete comparison - what each stone is, how they look, hardness, price, settings, meaning, and which buyer each one suits. Honest, expert, and practical.

Read more
What Is a Herkimer Diamond? Origin, Meaning, Value & Complete Guide

What Is a Herkimer Diamond? Origin, Meaning, Value & Complete Guide

Half a billion years in the making, found in a single county in New York, and named "diamond" by people who had never seen anything like them. Here is everything...

Read more
Black Rings for Women: Meaning, Styles and How to Choose

Black Rings for Women: Meaning, Styles and How to Choose

The complete guide to black rings for women: black diamonds, onyx, obsidian, and more. Discover the meaning, styles, and what makes black rings so captivating.

Read more
Herkimer Diamond Ring Durability - The Complete Daily-Wear Guide

Herkimer Diamond Ring Durability - The Complete Daily-Wear Guide

Herkimer diamond rings are raw, light-catching, and beautifully non-traditional—but they are not actual diamonds. Here’s what Herkimer diamonds are, how durable they really are, and which settings make them safest...

Read more
What Is a Salt and Pepper Diamond? Complete Guide

What Is a Salt and Pepper Diamond? Complete Guide

Real natural diamonds with visible black and white inclusions — and 70-85% cheaper than colorless. The complete expert guide to what salt and pepper diamonds are, what causes the inclusions,...

Read more

Herkimer Diamond Engagement Rings FAQs

Explore More About Herkimer Diamond Engagement Rings

Browse related collections and resources to find the right setting, metal, and style at Aquamarise®.